MEDICAL VACATIONS
by Stan Seagraves, M.D.
We
are all familiar with the notion of a vacation on the
Mexican Riviera or an Indonesian jungle adventure. But what
about dental implants in Chihuahua or a hip replacement in
Bangkok? Or open heart surgery in Mumbai? Welcome to the
world of “medical tourism.” As health care costs approached
the stratosphere, “western” medical training and technology
reached the developing world. So there is no mystery as to
why enterprising practitioners and cost-savvy healthcare
consumers found one another.
The biggest driver of this phenomenon – it’s far beyond a
fad or trend at this point – is the virtually uncontrolled
rate of medical spending in the United States. This,
combined with the ever-increasing ranks of uninsured or very
high deductible patients have created a ripe opportunity for
international medical clinics and hospitals. Paradoxically,
so too have the wait-lists and access limitations in many
government-run western health care systems. “Let's see – I
can wait 18 months for the hip replacement, or get 'er done
in 3 weeks in India, for about the price of a motorcycle.”
These facilities are not grimy ramshackle huts crawling
with rodents and dispensing snake-oil. Rather, these are
very much modern and western hospitals; many of them are
hotel-like, catering to western tastes, treating in a
conventional/allopathic fashion. They are staffed by
providers with traditional training – many of them coming
from highly regarded teaching programs in the U.S and U.K.
Some foreign hospitals even have formal collaborative
arrangements with respected U.S. hospitals.
So why fly to Singapore for that valve replacement
surgery? How about the $13,500 vs. $170,000 bill for total
treatment costs? How about that new knee? Fifty grand in the
good ol' U.S.A. vs. $11,500 in Costa Rica . Granted, travel
is not included. However, you can fly first class – maybe on
the Concorde - and still pocket a tidy sum. You'll want to
fly first class and fast, too, because you may be eager to
recover elsewhere but in a foreign hotel.
Flippancy aside, the cost differences are staggering – on
the order of 70% of U.S. costs, generally. So there must be
a catch, right? Terrible quality, unsanctioned work? Not
necessarily. In fact, the Joint Commission on the
accreditation of hospitals, the U.S hospital credentialing
agency, has an international branch, and has certified
hospitals in many countries. It's admittedly hard to make
quality comparisons between, say, Hungary and the U.S., but
then again, it’s often difficult to compare quality between
Utah and Florida. Many overseas hospitals stack up quite
favorably on typical quality indicators, with U.S.
facilities.
Some insurance carriers have caught on to the potential
here, and now offer significant inducements to clients who
get their care in other countries. Depending upon the
direction that U.S. Health care follows, and particularly if
a market-driven option is facilitated, we may see a huge
increase in the breadth and depth of foreign competition for
American health care dollars.
There are significant issues that one must contend with
if contemplating overseas health care. Travel and its costs
and complications, recovery issues, post-operative follow-up
and malpractice differentials are substantial. Nonetheless,
international health care is just one more example of, as
Thomas Freidman aptly named it, our globe’s 'flattening'.
Tummy tuck in Timbuktu, anyone? |