Another Vaccine Controversy
by Stan Seagraves, M.D.
If you've got kids above the age of 11, you may have
heard something about the vaccine against HPV at the doctors
office. However, you are more likely to have heard about the
controversy surrounding it in the lay press, because the HPV
vaccine is unique in its occupation of the intersections of
health, sexuality, public policy and drug company marketing.
The human papillomavirus (HPV) family of viruses cause a
variety of human illnesses. Some varieties cause the common
and benign hand and foot warts that many are familiar with.
More importantly, several “species” of these viruses are
sexually transmitted and can cause cervical cancer in women,
and genital warts in both sexes. Even though most women who
contract the virus do not develop illness, nearly a quarter
of a million women die each year worldwide from cervical
cancer, and HPV is now recognized as the causative agent in
the majority of cases. HPV is the most prevalent sexually
transmitted disease on the planet. Cervical cancer is the
second commonest cause of cancer deaths in women. This is a
very big deal.
There are currently two vaccines on the market – Gardasil
and Cervarix - both shown to be very effective against the
two virus strains most implicated in cervical cancer. And
both vaccines have been demonstrated to be extremely safe.
Both are made by mega-pharmaceutical companies; Gardasil by
Merck, Cervarix by GlaxoSmithKline.
So we have a common and potentially lethal disease that
has a safe, effective and readily available preventive
vaccine – what's the fuss about?
Unquestionably, the biggest deal is the fact that we are
talking about a sexually transmitted disease. There is a
notion among some that vaccinating adolescents encourages
early and irresponsible sexual activity. Sadly, abundant
epidemiological data suggest that teens need no such
encouragement: 62% of 12 graders are sexually active, as are
33% of 9th graders. Good data has also shown that fear
of cancer is NOT a deterrent to sexual activity. Pregnancy
yes, STD's yes – but HPV, based on its hit or miss nature
and long time frame from infection to clinical disease, does
not get this age groups attention.
“Well, its not like measles or something – you can't
avoid that – sexually transmitted stuff is preventable
through abstinence”. Well, yes and no. If you NEVER become
sexually active, you are in safe territory. But read this
sentence twice: 14% of women age 18-25 with ONE lifetime
sexual partner STILL have HPV. I think you can figure out
how this can be true. More depressing news: 12% of 9-12th
grade girls report being forced into sexual activities, as
do 9% of boys.
“Well, OK, but we are a very strong Christian family and
we have taught the importance of purity to our children and
I just don't think that this applies to our situation.”
First of all, good for you for prioritizing abstinence
education. It can be a difference maker. I wish it were
enough. But please read the above paragraph again. Next
ponder this sobering statistic: adolescents who label
themselves as “evangelicals” actually have a slightly HIGHER
rate of teen sexuality and a higher percentage of multiple
(>3) partners – the prevalence is 13.7% - than those that
are “non-evangelicals.” We can quibble till sunrise about
the validity of some of the surveys behind these numbers –
but we cannot hide from the fact that Americas teens are
highly sexualized and are at greater risk than many realize.
Another “turn-off” for parents has been the patronizing
attitude of some health care providers. Treating skeptical
or questioning parents as stupid and naive while prancing
about on one's white public health horse is not winning over
confused and legitimately concerned parents. Taking the time
to discuss the rationale and recommendations in a
non-judgmental fashion would seem like a natural approach –
if your provider cannot do this, shop around.
So.............do your homework, be honest with yourself
and your kids, ask your primary provider the hard questions,
and give this vaccine serious consideration. |